All are from the original series with John Daly....no Bruner or Blyden episodes.
* means a couple minutes of this episode not involving mystery guest are missing. 
Listing is alphabetical by first name of mystery guest. When there are two 
ystery guests each is listed separately. #'s are my tape locator numbers

Abbe Lane (1967) #60
Admiral Halsey (1951) #63
Alan Arkin (1965)/cast of "Luv" #18
Alan King (1962) #110
Alan King (1963) #124
Allan Sherman (1964) #10
Allan Sherman (1965) #22
Allan Sherman (1967) #50
Alfred Hitchcock (1954) #15
Allen Funt (1963) #111
Allen Ludden/Betty White (1965) #15
Allen & Rossi (1964) #13
Allen & Rossi (1966) #38
Allen & Rossi (1967)
Andre Kostelanetz (1954) #90
Andy Devine (1952) #67
Andy Griffith (1958) #114
Andy Griffith (1965) w/o/c #22,#68
Andy Griffith (1967) #64
Andy Williams (1963) #110
Angela Lansbury (1966) #49
Anita Ekberg (1958) #12
Ann Miller (1956) #140 woc
Ann Sheridan (1952) #63
Ann Sothern (1953) #86, #130
Ann Sothern (1965) #17
Anna Magnani (1953) #73
Anna Marie Alberghetti (1961) #112
Anne Bancroft (1963) #5
Anne Bancroft (1964) #16
Anne Jackson (1965)/cast of "Luv" #18
Anthony Newley (1965/Joan Collins #20
Anthony Perkins (1963) #35
Anthony Quinn (1963) #111
Anthony Quinn/Billy Graham (1960) #74
Arlene's Co-Stars in Dinner at Eight (1966) #61
Arlene Dahl (1954) #94
Arnold Stang (1955) #43
Art Carney (1954) #42, #96
Art Carney (1965) #18
Art Carney/Walter Cronkite (1966) #36
Art Linkletter (1956) w/o/c #48
Art Linkletter (1965) #20
Arthur Godfrey (1952) #63
Arthur Godfrey (1963) #112

Arthur Godfrey (1966) #39

Artie Shaw (1950) #130

Audie Murphy (1955) #113

Arthur Murry (1960) #122

Audrey Meadows (1955) #124

Ava Gardner (1953) #46,#84

Barbara Ann Scott (1955) #115

Barbra Streisand (1964) #11

Barbra Streisand (1965) #19

Barry Fitzgerald (1952) #71

Bea Lillie (1956) #15

Bea Lillie (1964) #11

Ben Gazzara (1963) #110

Benny Goodman (~1958)* #72

Benny Goodman/Miss Universe (1962) #64

Bert Lahr (1964) #10.#62

Bette Davis (1952) #70

Bette Davis (1962) #6, #108

Bette Davis (1964) #10

Bette Davis (1965)/Danny Kaye #24

Betty Comden&Adolph Green (1967 #58)

Betty Grable (1965) #22

Betty Hutton (1956) #43

Bill Cullen (1961) #35

Billy Graham/Anthony Quinn (1960) #74

Billy Rose 1953 #85

Bishop Fulton J. Sheen (1956) #139

Bob Cummings (1959) #9

Bob Cummings (~1961) #37 

Bob Cummings (1964) #13

Bob Hope (1954) also have this w/o/c #13,#24

Bob Hope (1956) #116

Bob Hope & Lucille Ball (1963) #34

Bob Newhart (1962) #21

Bobby Darin (1962) #3

Brandon de Wilde (1954) #90

Buddy Hackett (~1962) #14

Buddy Hackett (1964) #16

Buddy Hackett (1965) #26

Buffalo Bob Smith (1954) #27 and woc and #135

Burl Ives (1955) #95

Burns & Allen (1954) #23, and woc and 135

Buster Keaton (1957) #95, #99

Carl Sandburg/Milton Berle (1960) #119

Carol Baker (1964) #12

Carol Burnett (1961) #16

Carol Burnett (1964) #10

Carol Burnett (1966) #26,#36

Carol Channing (1963) #34

Carol Channing (1964) #13

Carol Channing&Ginger Rogers (1965)/Lucy #21

Carol Channing (1966) #26

Carol Lawrence (1963) #113

Casey Stengel (1962) #18

CBS News Team/Perle Mesta (1956) #95

Cesar Romero (1952) #78

Charles Boyer (1962) #3

Charles Boyer (1963)#8

Charles Coburn (1953) #85

Charles Laughton (1956) #103

Charlton Heston (1956) #139 woc

Chubby Checker/Joan Collins (1962) #35

Chuck Dressen (1952) #70

Claudette Colbert (1956) #11

Connie Francis (1961) #110

Conrad Hilton (1955) w/o/c panel dons coonskin caps#48

Cyd Charrise (1956) first ep after death of Fred Allen #29

Dan Dailey (1954) #50

Danny Kaye (1965)/Bette Davis #24

Danny Kaye/Abe Ribicoff (1966) #61

Danny Thomas (1957) #123

Darryl Zanuck (1958) #124

Dave Garroway (1953) #47

David McClelland, Sen. (1955) #56, #107

David Merrick/Henry&P. Fonda (1966) #39

Debbie Reynolds (1954) Eddie Fisher cameo #100

Debbie Reynolds (1959) #108

Debbie Reynolds (1964) #10

Deborah Kerr (1953) #125

DeMarco Sisters (1953) #75

Dennis Day (1955) #50

Desi Arnaz (1952) #71

Dick Powell (1954) #43

Dick Powell (1960) #7

Dick Powell (1962) #2

Don Ameche (1953) #80

Doris Day (1954) her first tv appearance #97

Dorothy Lamour (1955) #56

Dorothy Lamour (1958) #17

Dorothy McGuire (1954) #41, #98

Duke Ellington (1953) #82

Duke Snyder (1959)/Bob Cummings #9

Duke Snyder and Sal Maglie woc and #135

Earle Stanley Gardner (1957)/George Sanders #5

Eartha Kitt (1954) #97

Eartha Kitt (1962) #3

Ed Sullivan (1958) #109

Ed Sullivan (1963) #124

Ed Sullivan/Suzy Knickerbocker (1966) #61

Ed Wynn (1953) #21

Edie Adams/Ernie Kovacs (1956) 

Eddie Bracken (1952) #69

Eddie & Marilyn Cantor (mid 50s) #99

Eddie Fisher&Debbie Reynolds (1956) #65

Eddie Fisher (1952) in army uniform #71

Eddie Fisher (early 60s) #36

Eddie Fisher (1964) #16

Edgar Bergen (1954) #50

Edgar Bergen (1956) #23

Edgar and Candace Bergen (1965) #22

Edie Adams (1964) #11

Edward G. Robinson (1953) #12, #87

Edward G. Robinson (1956) #19

Edward G. Robinson (1962) #73

Edward G. Robinson (1965) #26

Edward R. Murrow (1952) #77

E.G. Marshall (1964) #12

Eleanor Roosevelt (1953) #50,#87

Eli Wallach (1965)/cast of "Luv" #18

Elizabeth Ashley (1964) #16

Elizabeth Taylor (1954) #29

Ella Fitzgerald (1961) #7

Ella Fitzgerald (1962) w/o/c #25

Elsa Maxwell (1950) #66

Emmett Kelly (1956) #132

Ernie Kovacs/Edie Adams (1956) #140 woc

Errol Flynn w/o/c #30

Esther Williams (1955) #134

Estes Kefauver, Sen. (1951) #63

Ethel Barrymore (1952) #70

Ethel Merman (1963) #34

Ethel Merman (1965) #21

Eva Gabor (1954) #31

Eva Gabor&Eddie Albert (1966) #36

Eva Marie Saint (1966) #60

Eve Arden (1955) woc and #135 

Everitt Dirksen (1967) #58

Eydie Gorme (1963) #125

Ezio Pinza (1953) #88

Fernando Lamas (1954) #45, #101

Floyd Patterson (1956) #139 woc

Ford Frick (1956)

Frank Fontaine (1964) #12

Frank Gifford (1956)/Milton Berle, 1956 #21

Frank Sinatra/Mia Farrow (1966) #49

Frankie Laine (1952) #67

Frankie Laine (1960) #108

Fred Allen (1953) #85

Fred Allen (1955) #23 and #136 woc

Fred Astaire (1955) #108, #115

Fred Astaire (1960) #120

Fred McMurray (1953) #7, #78

Fred McMurray (1959) #125

Frederick March (1954) #125

Gary Crosby (1956) #51

Garry Moore (1955) #133

Gen. Van Fleet (1953) #82

Gene Autry (1953) Dorothy hits a free guess! #44, #87

Gene Kelly (1957) #123

Gene Kelly (1964) #15

Genevieve (1961) #122

George Burns (1961) #13

George Burns (1964) #10

George Hamilton (1965) #20

George Hamilton (1966) #61

George Jessel (1965) #18

George Raft (1953) #19, #88 

George Sanders (1957)/Earle S. Gardner #5

Geraldine Chaplin (1966) #26

Geraldine Page (1963) #109

Gertrude Berg (1954) #42

Gertrude Berg (1961) #119

Gina Lollabrigida (1964) #11

Gina Lollabrigida (1967) #60

Ginger Rogers (1954) #31

Ginger Rogers (1963) #8

Gisell MacKenzie (1960 #109)

Gloria Swanson (1965) fifteenth anniversary show #17

Gordon McCrae (no Sheila, early 60s) #14

Gordon & Sheila McCrae #2

Gordon & Sheila McCrae (1965) #24

Gracie Fields (1955) #134

Greer Garson (1953) #1

Greer Garson (1958) #126

Groucho Marx (1963) #8

Guy Lombardo (1950) #66

Gwen Verdon (1966) #39

Hal March (1955) #131

Haley Mills (1965) #24

Harold Lloyd (1953) #81, #99

Harry Belafonte (1955) #133

Harry Belafonte (1966) #26

Helen Hayes (1964) #11

Helen Traubel (1954) #91

Henry Cabot Lodge (1956) #51

Henry Fonda (1964) #13

Henry Fonda (1965)/Sean Connery #23

Henry&Peter Fonda/D. Merrick (1966) #39

Herb Alpert & Tijuana Brass (1967) #16

Herb Shriner (1952) #71

Herbert Marshall (1954) #105

Hermione Gingold (1963) #9

Hildegarde (1955) #53, #102

Hope Lange (1958) #113

Horst Bucholz (1962) #23

Hosts of Goodson-Todman shows (1967) #59

Hugh Hefner (1966)/Polly Bergin #16

Hugh O'Brian (~1962) #15

Hugh O'Brian (1967) #117

Ida Cantor (1953) #81

Imogene Coca (1956) #132

Ingemar Johanssen (1960) #120

Irene Dunne (1953) #76

I've Got a Secret Panel (1956) #132

Ivy Baker Priest (1954) on ep. with Debbie Reynolds#100

Jack Benny (1953) #23

Jack Benny (1959) #50

Jack Benny/Vince Edwards (1966) #39

Jack Dempsey (1965) #21

Jack Jones (1965) #19

Jack Jones (1967) #58

Jack Lemmon (1960) #126

Jack Lemmon (1964) #11

Jack Lemmon (1965) also have as w/o/c #17, #27, #68

Jack E. Leonard (1962) #1

Jack E. Leonard (1964) #15

Jack E. Leonard (1967) #59

Jack Palance (1955) #29

Jack Palance (1964) #12

Jack Parr (1958) #126

Jack Parr (1960) #32

Jackie Cooper #30

Jackie Cooper (1956) #133

JackieGleason (1953) #46, #79

James Cagney (1960) #19

James Garner (1964) #16

James Mason (1956) w/o/c #40

James Mason (1965) #17

Jane Fonda (1964) #10

Jane Fonda (1967) #60

Jane Froman (1953) #75

Jane Powell (1956) #137 woc

Jane Russell (1962) #6

Jane Wyatt/Robert Young (1962) #118

Jane Wyman (1960) #121

Janet Leigh (1954) #14, #94

Janet Leigh (1960) #13

Janet Leigh (1961) #14

Jason Robards (1965) #15

Jayne Mansfield (1956) #12

Jayne Mansfield(1964) #11

Jayne Mansfield (1966) #38

Jayne Meadows (1954) #98

Jean Hersholt (early 50s) #69

Jean Pierre Aumont (1955) #117

Jean Pierre Aumont (1963) #126

Jean Pierre Aumont/Marisa Pavan (1966) #38

Jean Simmons (1955) #52

Jeanette McDonald (1952) #78

Jeanne Crain (1954) her first tv appearance #42,#96

Jeanne Crain (1963) #108

Jeff Chandler (1954) #45,#101

Jerry Lewis (1956) #127

Jerry Lewis (~1962) #49

Jesse Owens (1960) #120

Jill St. John (1965) #22

Jill St. John (1967) #72

Jimmy Durante (1965) #17

Jimmy Stewart (1963) #8,#93

Jo Stafford (1956) #54

Joan Collins/Chubby Checker (1962) #35

Joan Collins (1965)/Anthony Newley #20

Joan Crawford (1961)/Wilt Chamberlain #33

Joan Crawford (1962) #6

Joan Crawford (1964) #15

Joan Crawford (1966) #37

Joan Fontaine (1954) #91

Joe E. Brown (1953) #76

Joe E. Lewis (1955) #57, #122

Joe DiMaggio (1955) #57

Joey Hetherton (1965) last Dorothy/is w/o/c #27

John Daly (1967) last episode #64

John Hodiak (1954) #91

John McClellan (1955) #56

John Wayne (1960) #33

Johnny Carson (1963) #22

Johnny Mathis (1959) #20

Johnny Olson/Maurice Chevalier (1965) #117

Johnny Olson (1965) 

Johnnie Ray (1954) w/o/c #48

Jonathan Winters (1960) #13

Jonathan Winters (1964) #9

Jose Ferrer (1955) #119

Judy Canova (1954) Arlene hits a free guess! #98

Judy Garland (1967) #5

Judy Holliday (1953) #15,#83

Judy Holliday (1958) #40

Julie Andrews (1960) tenth anniversary #60

Julie London (1957) Bennett subs as host! #69

Julius LaRosa (1954) #90

June Allyson (1960) #113

June Havoc (1953) #76

June Taylor Dancers (1956) #140 woc

Karl Mundt, Sen. (1954) #41

Kate Smith (1965) #26

Kim Novak (1956) w/o/c #2, #24

Kingston Trio (1963) #8

Kirk Douglas (1953) #44

Lana Turner (1966)/Supremes #36

Lauren Bacall (1953) last w/contestants walking #44,#88

Lauren Bacall (1965) #26

Lawrence Welk (1967) #50

Lee Remick (1965) #15

Lee Remick (1966) #39

Lena Horne (1953) #46,#84

Leo Durocher (1953) #80

Lerner&Lowe/Bishop Sheen (1956) #139

Leslie Uggams (1967) #50

Les Paul & Mary Ford (1954) #41

Liberace (1956) #127

Liberace (1964) #11

Lilly Pons (1955) Bennett hits on free guess #31

Linda Darnell (1956) #132

Liza Minelli (1965) #20

Louella Parsons (1953) first w/contest. not walking #89

Louella Parsons (1964) #89

Louis Armstrong (mid 1950's) #15

Louis Armstrong (1964) #10

Louis Jordan (1954) #105

Lucille Ball (1954) w/o/c #25

Lucille Ball (1961) #14

Lucille Ball & Bob Hope (1963) #34

Lucille Ball (1965a)/Channing & Rogers #21

Lucille Ball (1965b) #17

Lucy & Desi (1955) w/o/c #25,#65

McGuire Sisters (1955) #15,#104

McGuire Sisters (1964) #4, #11

Margaret O'Brien (1958) #114

Margaret Sullavan (1955) #55

Margaret Chase Smith, Sen. (1953) #83

Margaret Truman (1953) #76

Marge&Gower Champion (1955) #102

Martha Raye (1955) #55

Marian Anderson (1965) #19

Marilyn Maxwell (1953) #81

Marisa Pavan (1956) #54

Mary Healy (1956) #43

Maureen O'Sullivan (1965) first post-Dorothy ep #24,#27

Maurice Chevalier (1963) #14

Maurice Chevalier (1965) 

Melina Mercouri (1962) #6

Melina Mercouri (1967) #58

Merle Oberon (1954) * first time panel walks on #45

Mia Farrow/Frank Sinatra (1966) #49

Michael Caine (1966) #49

Michael Redgrave (1960) #15

Mickey Mantle (1953) #9, #80

Mickey Rooney (1961) #17

Milton Berle (1956)/Frank Gifford #21

Milton Berle/Carl Sandburg (1960) #119

Milton Berle (1965) #21

Miss America (1952) Arlene hits free guess! #69

Miss America 1961 (1962) #121

Miss America (1963) #2

Mitch Miller (1963) #5, #8

Miyoshi Umecki #1958) #118

Molly Goldberg (1954) #96

Montgomery Clift (1962) #112

Muhammad Ali (1965) #22

Nancy Sinatra (1966) #34, #47

Nancy Sinatra/Tommy Sands (1967) #14

Nancy Walker (1963) #119

Nanette Fabray (1956) #139 woc

Nanette Fabray & Robert Ryan (1962) #4

Nat King Cole (1953) #93

Nat King Cole (1961) #33

Natalie Wood (1966) #39

Nelson Eddy (1953) #83, #130

Noel Coward (1964) #9

Olivia DeHavilland (1958) #62

Olivia DeHavilland (1963) #24

Olivia DeHavilland (1964) #13

Olivia DeHavilland (1965) * #22

Olsen & Johnson (1953) #130

Oscar Levant (1965) #24

Ozzie&Harriet Nelson (1956) #65

Paul Anka (1962) #9

Paul Anka (1964)#13

Paul Douglas (1953) #75

Paul Ford (1963) #121

Paul Ford (1966) #36

Paul Muni (1955) #131

Paul Newman (1958) #14

Paul Newman&Joanne Woodward (1959) #65

Pearl Bailey (1955) fifth anniversary #56

Pearl Bailey (1964) #9

Pearl Bailey (1966) #47

Peggy Cass (1967) #59

Peggy King (1955) #57

Perle Mesta (1952) #67

Perle Mesta/CBS News Team (1956) from Chicago #95

Peter Lawford (1953) #115, #83

Peter Lawford (1964) #12

Peter Lind Hayes/Mary Healy (1955) #55

Peter Lorre (1960) #18

Peter, Paul and Mary w/o/c #30

Peter Ustinov (1966) #47

Phil Rizzuto (1950) first show #28

Phil Silvers (1955) #52

Phyllis Diller (1963) #111

Piper Laurie (1963) #9

Polly Bergen (1958) #32

Polly Bergen (1961 or 1962) #20

Polly Bergen (1966)/Hugh Hefner #16

Portland Hoffa (1955) #53

Raquel Welch (1967) #50

Raquel Welch (1966) #12

Ray Bolger (1956) * #37

Ray Milland (1954) #45

Ray Milland (1965) #24

Raymond Burr (1962) #117

Red Buttons (1953) #79

Red Buttons (1962) #118

Red Skelton (1954)/Roy Rogers & Dale Evans #13

Rhonda Fleming (1955) #108

Richard Boone (1963) #8

Richard Widmark (1954) #90

Ricky Nelson (1959) #32

Ritz Brothers (1961) #33

Robert Goulet (1962) #4

Robert Goulet (1965) #20

Robert Q. Lewis (1955) #136 woc

Robert Mitchum (1957) #93

Robert Mitchum (1965) #18

Robert Morse (1967) #50

Robert Presont (1963) #118

Robert Preston (1966) #36

Robert Taylor (1956) #132

Robert Wagner, Mayor of NYC (1954) #44, #89

Robert Wagner (1961) #111

Robert Young (1957) #7

Robert Young & Jane Wyatt (1958) #73

Robert Young/Jane Wyatt (1962) #118

Rochester (1952) #15, #77

Rodgers&Hammerstein (1956) #51

Ronald Reagan (1953) w/o/c #46, #82

Rosalind Russell (1953) #78

Rosemary Clooney (1955) #107

Rosemary Clooney (~1963) #61

Roy Campanella (1953) #84

Roy Rogers & Dale Evans (1954)/Red Skelton #13

Rudy Vallee (1964) #12

Sal Maglie (1956) #140 woc

Sally Rand (1952) #78

Sammy Davis Jr. (1955) #127

Sammy Davis Jr. (1957) w/o/c #30

Sammy Davis Jr. (1962) #18

Sean Connery (1965)/Henry Fonda #23

Sen. McClelland (1955) #106

Schiaparelli, Mme. (1952) #70

Shelley Winters (1955) #56

Shelley Winters (1966) #38

Sheree North (1955) #136 woc

Shirley Booth (1953) #81

Shirley Booth (1962) #47

Shirley Jones (1962) #58

Sid Caesar (1963)#112

Simone Signoret (1964) #11

Sir Ralph Richardson (1963) #121

Smothers Brothers (1967) #64

Soupy Sales (1965) #19

Soupy Sales (1966) #39

Sophia Loren (1960) #12

Sophia Loren (1958) #122

Sophia Loren (1961) #35

Sophie Tucker (1963) #8

Spike Jones (1954) #41

Stan Musial (1964)/Steve Allen #10

Steve Allen (1953) #29

Steve Allen (1964)/Stan Musial #10

Steve Allen (1964) John does a blooper #15

Steve Lawrence & Edy Gorme (1962) #3

Steve Lawrence & Edy Gorme (1964) #15

Steve McQueen (1966) #60

Sue Lyon (1964) #12

Supremes (1966)/Lana Turner #36

Supremes (1967) #50

Sylvana Mangano (!956) #137 woc

Tab Hunter (1957) w/o/c #40, #48

Tallulah Bankhead (1965) #20

Ted Lewis )1956) #137 woc

Ted Williams (1954) #31, #97

Tenn. Ernie Ford (1960) #109

Terry Moore (1955) #53, #108

Tom Ewell (1955) #134

Tommy&Jimmy Dorsey (1955 #52, #133

Tommy Sands (1967)/Nancy Sinatra #14

Tony Bennett (1964) #16

Tony Curtis (1955) #103 , #134

Tony Martin (1962) #4

Tony Randall (1964) #13

Tony Randall (1967) #64

Tyrone Power (1955) #53

Tuesday Weld (1962) #19

Van Heflin (1955) #52

Van Heflin (1964) #9

Van Cliburn (1962) #26

Van Cliburn (1964) #11

Van Johnson (1955) #57, #102

Vaughn Meader (1962) #127

Vaughn Monroe (1954) #42

Vic Damone (1952) in army uniform #77

Vic Damone and Pier Angeli (1956) #137 woc

Victor Borge (1952) #68

Victor Borge (1956) #51

Victor Borge (1963) #8

Vince Edwards/Jack Benny (1966) #39

Vince Lombardi #16

Vincent Price (1956) #139 woc

Virna Lisi (1966) #49

Vivian Blaine (1955) #55

Wally Cox (1953) #84

Walt Disney (1956) #95

Walter Brennan (1966) #47

Walter Cronkite/Art Carney (1966) #36

Walter Pidgeon (1956) #140 woc

Walter Pidgeon (1962) #60

Walter Winchell (1952) #77

Warren Beatty (1966) #47

William Bendix (1953) #93

William Bendix (1954) #94

William Holden (1956) #140 woc

Willie Mays (1954) #49

Willie Mays (1962) #9
Wilt Chamberlain (1961)/Joan Crawford #33
Woody Allen (1965) #23
Woody Allen (1966) #36
Woody Allen (1967) #59
Xavier Cugat (1958) #123
Yogi Berra (1961) #120
Yves Montand (1967) #64
Yves St. Laurent (1965)
Zsa Zsa Gabor (1953) #79
Zsa Zsa Gabor (1957) #14, #32
 

I have one ep from Oct., 1950 with no mystery guest. #66